Caste Out


Direct Answers - Column for the week of September 29, 2003

I am a 28-year-old Indian lady. I am in love with a 30-year-old Indian guy for the last four years. We share many interests in common and get along well. We are both Ph.D. students.

The problem is the different communities to which we belong. We have a very complex social system and are allowed to marry only the person who belongs to our own community (caste). He belongs to a higher community than mine.

My boyfriend feels he would never be able to convince his parents for the marriage, nor has he attempted this. He strongly believes he would not be happy if he hurts his parents, so two years ago he asked me to stop contacting him. It was very painful for me, but at the same time I realized I cannot force him into a relationship.

We live in separate towns now. Until two months ago we had absolutely no contact, then he started contacting me. I know from his letters he is frustrated and lonely. Even though I stopped communicating with him, I love him with all my heart and cannot think of life with another man.

I answered his letters, which are mostly about academics, and never asked him why he broke up with me. I haven't discussed my future with him nor he with me. Things look so uncertain I am confused. Should I continue with him or not?

Reeta

Reeta, there are many reasons why people feel they are better than other people. A religious person might say we are full of pride, and our pride makes us want to feel superior. A scientist might say we are primates and primates arrange themselves in dominance hierarchies. But the reasons for social differences don't matter.

What matters is that you are revisiting a round of pain this man caused you two years ago. You are a bright, educated woman worthy of a man's love. Though you may care for him and he may care for you, he is letting something other than love make his choices.

He is not offering you marriage or apologizing for cutting you out of his life two years ago. He is wheedling his way back into your life in the same wheedling way he left it. He is coming back because he is lonesome, not because he is ready to defend you as the woman he loves.

When a person cannot swim, it doesn't mean they can jump in the water two years later unless something has changed. You need to tell him that.

If he hasn't changed, you are indulging yourself in something which can only cause you pain. If you give him a shoulder to cry on, all you are likely to get is a wet shoulder.

Wayne & Tamara

The Open Road

My name is June, and I have a friend, Mary. Mary is 45 and very overweight. We ride our Harleys together all the time. Mary wears her shirts tied up in a big knot, and her huge tummy sticks out. It is very, very unattractive and very embarrassing to me.

I watch people stare, I hear their comments, and I hate it. I'm five feet tall, petite, and I don't even wear my clothes like that. How can I talk to her without hurting her feelings?

June

June, perhaps the essence of riding a Harley is freeing yourself from scripts of conduct and norms of behavior. We all long to be free of a closed caste system where everyone knows our place. We long to express our uncensored individual self. That is what Mary gets out of riding her Harley.

You can't tell her what you feel without hurting her feelings. But letting go of the feeling that you are responsible for another's actions will give you the feeling of freedom Mary feels as she rides her motorcycle.

Wayne & Tamara

About The Author

Authors and columnists Wayne and Tamara Mitchell can be reached at www.WayneAndTamara.com.

Send letters to: Direct Answers, PO Box 964, Springfield, MO 65801 or email: DirectAnswers@WayneAndTamara.com.







Related News



500 $1 return airfares for inspirational Kiwis - Scoop.co.nz (press release)

500 $1 return airfares for inspirational Kiwis
Scoop.co.nz (press release), New Zealand -Oct 11, 2008
Well, we want to show our Aussie friends what makes us Kiwis special by giving away 500 $1 return fares to inspirational Kiwis making a difference in our ...

A ball of inspirational predictability - Surrey Now

Boston Globe

A ball of inspirational predictability
Surrey Now,  Canada -Oct 10, 2008
... Gary Fleder's extensive use of close-ups. Inspirational? Check. Predictable? Yep. But The Express is a safe bet for sports fans and non-cynics alike.
Football drama a genuine inspirational taleChicago Daily Herald
The ExpressBox Office Prophets
Review: The ExpressCollege Times
Film Threat - Lake County News
all 471 news articles

A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ... - Calgary Herald

A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ...
Calgary Herald,  Canada -Oct 10, 2008
by Hunter S. Thompson In high school my best buddy Gavin and I fancied ourselves literary snobs. We read Dostoevsky--he was our favourite--and Tolstoy and ...

Celebrating Kristin Pass, Aledo's favorite daughter - Dallas Morning News

Dallas Morning News

Celebrating Kristin Pass, Aledo's favorite daughter
Dallas Morning News, TX -5 hours ago
Hats off to Dallas Morning News colleague Michael Young and his inspirational story in today's Metro section about an amazing homecoming queen and her ...

'Inspirational' Blackburn mum-of-seven dies, 34 - Lancashire Telegraph

'Inspirational' Blackburn mum-of-seven dies, 34
Lancashire Telegraph, UK -Oct 11, 2008
By Catherine Pye » Four weeks ago she was given six months to live. Charmaine had drawn up a wish list of things she wanted to do with her final days, ...

'Without a Quarter in My Pocket': New Memoir Chronicles Cuban ... - MarketWatch

'Without a Quarter in My Pocket': New Memoir Chronicles Cuban ...
MarketWatch -Oct 8, 2008
SALEM, Ill., Oct 08, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Dr. Secundino E. Rubio's life is a series of inspirational stories. From his childhood in pre-Castro ...

Tatenda Tavaziva's journey to and at UMHB an inspirational story - Killeen Daily Herald

Tatenda Tavaziva's journey to and at UMHB an inspirational story
Killeen Daily Herald, TX -15 hours ago
Tatenda Tavaziva attends a football game at the University of Mary Hardin-Baylor. The current student body president arrived at the school in January 2005 ...

Marriage supporters' fundraiser brings inspirational film ... - Sioux Falls Argus Leader

Marriage supporters' fundraiser brings inspirational film ...
Sioux Falls Argus Leader, SD -Oct 11, 2008
Moviegoers can credit a group interested in promoting healthy marriages for bringing the inspirational movie "Fireproof" to Sioux Falls for a weeklong ...

An inspirational rabbit - North by Northwestern

An inspirational rabbit
North by Northwestern, IL -1 hour ago
By Patrick St. Michel ‘Twas not a good weekend for Northwestern. But let’s not dwell on how our school lost all potential respect once again on national TV ...


A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ... - Calgary Herald

Calgary Herald

A new generation of icky, angsty, inspirational books for teens ...
Calgary Herald,  Canada -Oct 10, 2008
Sure, they text and they Twitter and they play way too much Wii. But all those twitchy, tormented adolescent souls are still able to lose--and then ...